In many cases in involving the Probate Court, the moving party must present clear and convincing evidence to prevail. But what does that mean? The standard was explained (at least in part) in In re Knight, 372 Ga. App. 485 (2024).

Lillian Knight passed away, naming her daughter, Karen, as executor. Prior to her death, Lillian had added Karen to bank accounts as joint owner. After Karen was appointed executor, her brothers tried to have Karen removed as executor, requested an accounting, and asked the Probate Court to find that the bank accounts were part of the probate estate. The Probate Court ruled for the brothers, finding the accounts belonged to the estate.

On Appeal, the Court disagreed. “It is well settled under Georgia law that [s]ums remaining on deposit at the death of a party to a joint account belong to the surviving party or parties as against the estate of the decedent, unless there is clear and convincing evidence of a different intention at the time the account is created. OCGA § 7-1-813(a).” (Emphasis added).

Clear and convincing evidence’ is an intermediate standard of proof, greater than `the preponderance of evidence,’ but less than the `beyond a reasonable doubt’ standard applicable in criminal cases.” (Citation and punctuation omitted.) In re Estate of Mobley, 369 Ga. App. 326, 329(1), 893 S.E.2d 457 (2023). Whether there is sufficient evidence to overcome the presumption is typically a question for the fact finder. Godwin, 197 Ga. App. at 831(1), 399 S.E.2d 581; see also In re Estate of Burkhalter, 354 Ga. App. at 235, 840 S.E.2d 614 (following declaratory judgment hearing, probate court’s factual findings will be upheld if there is any evidence to support them).

The only testimony supporting the Probate Judge’s decision was testimony of the parties and the bank documents showing that Karen co-owned them with rights of survivorship. The Probate Court expressed concern regarding Lillian’s intent, but nonetheless ruled they were part of the estate. The Court of Appeals found “[t]he very fact that the probate court had “concerns” about Lillian’s intent essentially negates its finding of clear and convincing intent to overcome the presumption that the accounts belonged to Karen.” The Court went farther, finding that Karen’s conduct after her mother’s death was not relevant. The Court looks “to Lillian’s intent at the time the accounts were created.”

Additional Resources

In In re Mobley, 369 Ga. App. 326 (2023), “contradictory” evidence was not clear and convincing. See also In re Estate of Burton, 265 Ga. 122 (1995).

Published by
David McGuffey
Tags: JTWRS

Recent Posts

Remembering Keith Ronald Miles

The Elder Law community lost one of our own a few days ago. Keith Miles,…

2 weeks ago

Getting a recorded statement introduced in evidence

Elder law attorneys sometimes find themselves in various types of litigation ranging from guardianship cases,…

1 month ago

2027 Social Security COLA

Today the Social Security Administration announced the Cost of Living Adjustment for next year, posting…

1 month ago

Good Lawyers Solve Problems, They Don’t Create Them

Years ago I had the pleasure of knowing Arvin Reingold, a Chattanooga lawyer. He was…

2 months ago

Stock Research

When you're looking at investing, there is no substitute for qualified competent advice. Having said…

2 months ago

My Views on Investing

My thoughts on investing may or may not help you. I don't claim to be…

3 months ago