Cases

Marchesano v. Dekkers, 2006 Cal. App. Unpub. LEXIS 4356 (California Unpublished Opinions 2006)

Plaintiff filed suit for nursing home negligence alleging multiple causes of action. Defendant filed a demur which was granted as to “the causes of action for willful misconduct, elder abuse, and intentional infliction of emotional distress. The court struck the punitive damage allegations and prayer for non-economic damages, and denied a motion to add punitive damages pursuant to Calf. Code of Civil Procedure § 425.13.” Plaintiff filed a third amended complaint for negligence and wrongful death and renewed their motion to add punitive damages. After it was denied, Plaintiffs sought an interlocutory appeal, which was denied. Plaintiff’s then dismissed the action for wrongful death and the sole remaining claim was the survivor’s claim for negligence. The trial court granted Defendant’s motion for judgment on the pleadings after finding there were no economic damages and, therefore, no cause of action for negligence. Plaintiff then appealed, arguing that the trial court erred in sustaining the demur on willful misconduct. The court found that, arguendo, if a tort for willful misconduct is still viable, that sufficient facts were not alleged to state a cause of action; willful misconduct requires some intentional act embodying a degree of malice. The court rejected Plaintiff’s argument that Defendant’s failure to observe federal and state nursing home regulations was tantamount to willful misconduct. Plaintiffs also appealed the demur relating to elder abuse. The court found that a medical malpractice action could not be recast as an elder abuse case; the elder abuse cause of action and the medical malpractice cause of action are like a “toggle switch:” it is either one or the other. The court similarly held that Plaintiffs had not alleged facts sufficient to state a cause of action for intentional infliction of emotional distress or for punitive damages. Judgment on the pleadings was properly granted.

Published by
David McGuffey

Recent Posts

ADLs and IADLs

Activities of Daily Living and Instrumental Activities of Daily Living describe basic skills for getting…

2 days ago

Planning for Adult Children with Disabilities

Childhood Disability Benefits assist disabled children and adults who became disabled prior to age 22.…

3 days ago

Are Video Wills Valid?

Video Wills You might wonder whether you can make a video recording of yourself stating…

4 weeks ago

2025 Georgia Medicaid Transfer Penalty

2025 Georgia Medicaid Transfer Penalty If an applicant for long-term care Medicaid (e.g., nursing home…

4 weeks ago

Another Scam, and this one makes my blood boil

Recently, my dad died. While I was driving back from being sworn in as his…

2 months ago

Review of Georgia Cases on Testamentary Capacity

In Georgia, an individual has legal capacity to make a Will "when the testator has…

3 months ago